Imam Ridas Debate with the Zoroastrian Scholar

The interaction began with a focus on monotheism—a cornerstone of Islamic doctrine. Imam Rida articulated the Islamic view of God’s oneness, juxtaposing it against Zoroastrian dualism. In Zoroastrian belief, the existence of two opposing forces, Ahura Mazda and Angra Mainyu, introduces a dichotomous understanding of divinity. Imam Rida’s rebuttal meticulously dismantled this notion, emphasizing the absolute and indivisible nature of God in Islamic thought.

A pertinent aspect of the debate hinged upon the intellectual method employed by Imam Rida. He harnessed the Qur’anic verses and prophetic traditions (Hadith) to substantiate his claims. This approach not only showcased the depth of Islamic theology but also highlighted the reliance on scriptural evidence as a means to legitimacy, which is a hallmark of Shia scholarly tradition.

The Notion of Prophethood