Tanqih al-maqal of Abd Allah Mamqani

Addressing Critiques and Debates

Despite its impeccable structure, “Tanqih al-Maqal” has not escaped scrutiny. Critics have raised valuable points concerning Mamqani’s methodologies and his reliance on antiquated sources. The metaphor of a lighthouse, which both guides and warns, embodies the duality of his impact—while illuminating the path for faithful adherence to Islamic tradition, it simultaneously casts shadows of doubt on established norms. In this manner, Mamqani’s work has propelled an array of debates about the nature of religious authority and the requisite qualifications of narrators. The tension between tradition and innovation is palpably felt, echoing through the scholarly circles that dissect his contributions even to this day.

The Implications for Contemporary Scholarship